Two smartphones with 20MP sensors: Nokia Lumia 1520 vs Sony Xperia Z1 Compact (2)
After the first comparison, someone on the Facebook group " Nothing but a Nokia" asked me to do a similar comparison of the Nokia Lumia 1520 and Sony Xperia Z1 Compact, but in great lighting conditions.
That's a bit ironic, since most of the requests I got in the past years have been to test devices in less light, low light, inside or even almost complete darkness. Nevertheless: I like good light photography best myself, so I'm happy to oblige.
I made a few high-res shots from a nice house in my hometown, a scene I think I've shared before (not sure about it, a long time ago if so anyway). So both the devices were set to maximum resolution and 4:3 - equivalent of 19MP (4992 x 3744 pixels) on the Lumia 1520 and 20.6MP (5248 x 3936 pixels) on the Sony Xperia Z1 Compact.
I will show the resized versions first (click on the shots to see the originals on OneDrive). Mind you, these are the resized versions of the high-res originals. Nokia Lumia 1520 first, like in the previous comparison.
I do like the color rendition of the Lumia better personally, although the bushes in front of the house are quite green. In the EXIF you will see the Sony Xperia Z1 Compact was on manual settings, which I need to get the 20MP result (like I wrote a few times, you can't get high res in the "Superior Auto" setting). The Nokia Lumia 1520 was on auto settings however (more about that in a later post).
Next, a few 640 x 360 crops from these two results. Lumia 1520 first.
I think you can make up your own mind about this result. Again, you'll see more pixelation in the 20MP original of Sony's Xperia, but it's not as noticable as in the previous comparison, and the readibilty of "In medio virtus" ("virtue stands in the middle") the Sony Xperia Z1 Compact is clearly better. A few more crops. Nokia Lumia 1520 first as always.
With more pixelation Sony seems to gives a sharper impression in great light conditions I guess, but in the end the result is pretty noisy too, so I personally still prefer the high res results I get from the Lumia 1520 - but I'm looking forward to what you think as always.
In a next post, I will compare some of the shots taken in 5MP and 8MP - the last coming from the Sony's Xperia in the "Superior Auto" setting. With many other users, I still wish Nokia would add the 8MP setting in Nokia Camera as well, like I could choose on the 808 PureView (and I know they're reading this :-)
Anyway there's no 5MP setting on the Xperia, so this next comparison will be somewhat of a challenge. This post was just a short one I know, but I have a daily job to go to as well. If you appreciate what I'm doing here, please consider making a contribution and hit the "Donate" button on the right hand side of this page - thank you in advance! :-)